NATO's New Defence Strategy In Doubt Without 'Europe's Biggest Security Provider'

28 June 2016

The European Union and the United States plan to use two separate EU and Nato summits in the coming days to push reforms of the West's two main security pillars, aimed at reducing Europe's reliance on Washington in its own neighbourhood.

"Things are going to be a lot harder," said a senior Western defence official involved in EU-Nato cooperation. "Nato planned on linking itself up to a stronger European Union, not being the default option for a weakened, divided bloc."

Facing a more aggressive Russia, a migrant crisis and failing states on its borders, the European Union needs to "act autonomously if and when necessary", EU foreign policy chief Federica Mogherini will tell EU leaders today, as she unveils a five-year global strategy plan.

That symbolic step, which urges governments to coordinate defence spending, has strong support from Germany and France. But it could look hollow without Britain, which has the largest military budget in the EU, diplomats say.

One of five EU countries with the resources to command an overseas military mission for the bloc, Britain has been a big contributor to EU-led operations, paying about 15pc of the costs and providing assets.

Britain also leads the EU's counter-piracy 'Operation Atlanta' mission off the Horn of Africa, has ships patrolling the Mediterranean and is committed to providing troops for EU battle groups - although they have never been deployed.

Mogherini's proposals to EU leaders will include a call for EU-led missions to work with a new EU border guard to control migrant flows. That could be harder without British ships.

"What Britain does matters," said Nato Secretary-General Jens Stoltenberg. "Britain is the biggest security provider in Europe."

But fearing plans for an EU army, Britain has resisted closer European defence cooperation.

British Defence Secretary Michael Fallon said this month: "Nobody wants to see their troops controlled from Brussels."

Some hope that, without London blocking EU plans, France and Germany could lead what Berlin calls a "common defence union" to develop and share assets.

France has pushed the idea of an EU military headquarters, independent of Nato, to run missions.

After financial crises that have cut defence spending and Russia's annexation of Ukraine's Crimea, EU governments have said they will do more to guarantee their own security and cannot rely on the United States indefinitely.

As part of that, Nato and the European Union will cement their growing cooperation from the Baltics to the Aegean at a Nato summit in Warsaw in July. At the EU level, governments are discussing a common defence fund to pool resources to develop helicopters, drones, ships and satellites.

Until Britain's referendum vote to leave the EU, the United States had been looking to Britain, its main ally in Europe, to act as a bridge between Nato and the EU in the process.

That was designed to allow Washington to focus on other worries, including a resurgent Taliban in Afghanistan and China's militarisation of islands in the South China Sea.

Such concerns were underscored by US Secretary of State John Kerry yesterday, who flew to Brussels to meet Mogherini and Stoltenberg.

"The United States cares about a strong EU," Kerry said.

Immediately after Britain's referendum last week, Stoltenberg said Britain had assured him it remained committed to upholding Western stability. Britain could also join EU missions, even outside the bloc, as Canada and non-EU member Norway have done, although it would not be able to shape long-term strategy.

For now, the United States' focus appears to be urging Britain to take an even bigger role in Nato and avoid isolation.


Source :